Reports
Actions for Members' additional entitlements 2019
Members' additional entitlements 2019
A report has been tabled on the findings and recommendations from the annual review of the additional entitlements claimed by the Members of the New South Wales Parliament (Members) under the Parliamentary Remuneration Tribunal’s Determination (the Determination).
Members claimed $21.5 million of additional entitlements in 2018–19, 2.7 per cent less than the previous year. The decrease is largely attributable to the period in the lead up to the New South Wales State Election, from 26 January to 23 March 2019, during which Members are not permitted to use their Communications Allowance. In addition, Parliament did not sit from 23 November 2018 until 6 May 2019.
The review found one instance of material non‑compliance with the Determination relating to a Member who claimed the General Travel Allowance but did not provide evidence that the travel related to their parliamentary duties.
14 other departures from the administrative requirements of the Determination, mostly relating to the timing of Members’ claims were identified. The review also found two instances where it was unclear whether reimbursement of Members’ claims had been made strictly in accordance with the Determination.
The report makes three recommendations to the Department of Parliamentary Services to work with the Tribunal to clarify specific wording and requirements in the Determination.
The Auditor-General has reviewed the compliance of the Members of the NSW Parliament (Members) with certain requirements outlined in the Parliamentary Remuneration Tribunal's Determination (the Determination) for the year ended 30 June 2019.
The Auditor-General's review is designed to provide parliament with limited assurance about Members' compliance with the Determination. We analysed all claims made by Members during the 2018–19 financial year and tested a sample of transactions that we identified as having a greater risk of non-compliance in more detail. Our sample included claims submitted by 59 of the 159 Members.
Results
Our review identified one instance of material non-compliance with the Determination for the year ended 30 June 2019 relating to a Member who claimed the General Travel Allowance but did not provide evidence that the travel related to their parliamentary duties.
Our audit procedures identified 14 other departures from the administrative requirements of the Determination:
- 8 Members submitted their reconciliations for the Sydney Allowance after the due date
- 1 Member who elected to receive their Sydney Allowance as an annual payment, returned their unspent Sydney Allowance to the Department after the 30 September 2019 due date
- 5 Members' claims were not submitted to the Department for payment within 60 days of receipt or occurrence of the expense.
Our audit procedures identified two instances where it was unclear whether Members had been reimbursed for their costs in accordance with the Determination:
- The Determination specifies the Electorate to Sydney Travel Allowance is for travel between Members’ electorates and Sydney. In administering the allowance, the Department permitted Members’ claims for travel to and from their residence, which may be outside of their electorate. The Tribunal confirmed that this accords with the intent of the Determination.
- The Determination specifies the Communications Allowance reimburses Members for the cost of producing communications. One Member chartered flights to film materials used to produce communications and to perform parliamentary duties. The Member claimed the cost of flights under the General Travel Allowance, without apportioning any part to the Communications Allowance. The flights and the communication of the filmed material to constituents occurred during the blackout period, during which Members are not permitted to use their Communications Allowance. The Department determined that all travel costs can be claimed under the General Travel Allowance, even if the travel related to the production of communications during the blackout period.
Recommendation The Department should work with the Tribunal to:
|
Our audit procedures identified 25 other departures from the Department's administrative guidelines, which support the Determination. Twenty-five Members submitted their annual loyalty scheme declarations after the 31 July 2019 due date specified in the Department's administrative requirements. Their declarations stated that loyalty scheme benefits accrued using their parliamentary allowance and entitlements were not used for private purposes.
Background
The Parliamentary Remuneration Tribunal (the Tribunal) determines the salary and additional entitlements of Members of NSW Parliament (Members), which are set out in the Tribunal's annual Determination.
Actions for Members' Additional Entitlements 2018
Members' Additional Entitlements 2018
The Auditor-General, Margaret Crawford, today released a report on the annual review of additional entitlements claimed by Members of the New South Wales Parliament under the Parliamentary Remuneration Tribunal’s Determination. The review analysed all claims made by Members and tested a sample of claims paid for the year ended 30 June 2018 in more detail.
The review found one Member of Parliament did not materially comply with the Determination. The Member made two unsupported claims for the Electorate to Sydney Travel allowance during the year ended 30 June 2018. The Department of Parliamentary Services has asked the Member to repay these amounts.
A further 20 departures from the administrative requirements of the Determination were identified, all relating to the timing of Members’ claims.
The Auditor-General recommended the Department work with the Tribunal to provide more detailed guidance on the activities that meet the definition of 'parliamentary duties' and the documents Members should retain to comply with the Determination.
The Auditor General has reviewed the compliance of the Members of the NSW Parliament (Members) with certain requirements outlined in the Parliamentary Remuneration Tribunal's Determination (the Determination) for the year ended 30 June 2018.
The Auditor General's review is designed to provide Parliament with limited assurance about Members' compliance with the Determination. We analysed all claims made by Members during the 2017-18 financial year and tested a sample of transactions that we identified as having a greater risk of non compliance in more detail. Our sample included claims submitted by 60 of the 140 Members.
Actions for Members' Additional Entitlements 2017
Members' Additional Entitlements 2017
Actions for Assessment of the use of a training program
Assessment of the use of a training program
The Department of Finance, Services and Innovation (DFSI) and Service NSW's use of Franklin Covey's '7 Habits' program (the Program) met identified business needs according to a report released today by the Auditor-General for New South Wales Margaret Crawford.
This audit assesses the effectiveness and economy of the Department of Finance, Services and Innovation's, including Service NSW's, use of the Franklin Covey ‘7 Habits’ program (the Program). On 15 March 2018, the Hon. Victor Dominello MP, Minister for Finance, Services and Property, requested the Auditor General conduct this audit under section 27(B)(3)(c) of the Public Finance and Audit Act 1983 (the Act).
About the agencies
The Department of Finance, Services and Innovation (the Department) is the lead agency of the Finance, Services and Innovation cluster. The Department has a number of divisions and business units, including: ICT and Digital Government, Property and Advisory Group, Better Regulation, NSW Fair Trading, Government and Corporate Services, and Revenue NSW. At 30 June 2017, the Department (excluding Service NSW) had 5,239 full-time equivalent staff.
Service NSW is a central point of contact for customers accessing NSW Government Services. It is a Division of the Finance, Services and Innovation cluster and operates as an executive agency. As an executive agency, Service NSW is led by a Chief Executive Officer, who is responsible to the Minister for Finance, Services and Property but appointed by the Secretary of the Department of Finance, Services and Innovation. Service NSW was established in 2013 and has operated under the Finance, Services and Innovation cluster since July 2015. At 30 June 2017, Service NSW had 1,989 full-time equivalent staff.
About the Program
The Program that the Department and Service NSW are implementing, and which is the subject of this audit, is a professional development training course which focusses on organisational culture emphasising personal effectiveness, leadership development and change management. All staff in the Department and Service NSW will receive the training, which involves:
- a 360-degree assessment where every staff member receives feedback from their manager, direct reports, and peers
- a two-day training workshop, which will be delivered face to face by accredited facilitators
- 2 years of online access to all training materials created by the provider of the Program.
As part of the licensing arrangement purchased by the agencies, the Program also provides access (at no extra cost) to the full range of the provider's training and development courses that might be useful for other learning and development activities. This includes courses to improve staff capability in communication skills, leadership, productivity and customer engagement. The Department is considering using one of these courses to develop leadership capabilities. Service NSW has integrated three of these courses into its people development curriculum.
Service NSW commenced the first sessions of the Program in May 2017. At 24 April 2018, around 1,000 staff had undertaken the training. Service NSW expects all staff to complete the Program by June 2019.
The Department of Finance, Services and Innovation commenced the first sessions of the Program in August 2017. At 18 April 2018, around 175 staff had undertaken the training. The Department expects all staff to complete the Program by December 2019.
Audit objective and criteria
The audit sought to assess the effectiveness and economy of the Finance, Services and Innovation cluster’s use of the Program. In making this assessment, we considered whether:
- the Program is being used effectively, including whether
- there is an identified need for the Program
- the use of the Program meets the identified need
- Finance, Services and Innovation cluster agencies evaluate the effectiveness of the Program
- the Program is economical, including whether:
- the procurement complies with all relevant policies and processes
- funding and resources allocated to the Program are reasonable.
Sector-wide learnings Implementing robust learning and development frameworks
|
Actions for Solar Bonus Scheme
Solar Bonus Scheme
A NSW Auditor General’s Report has found that the NSW Government and its agencies grossly underestimated the cost and number of people that would install systems under the Solar Bonus Scheme.
By October 2010, the estimated cost of the Scheme, if it continued the way it was going, would have reached $3.988 billion. More than ten times the original estimate of $362 million. In response to the increased cost, the gross tariff for new applicants was reduced from 60 to 20 cents reducing the estimated cost to $1.954 billion.
It was a statutory requirement that when 50 mega watts of installed capacity was reached, the Government would review the Scheme. By the time the review was completed the installed capacity had reached 101 mega watts.