Reports
Transport 2018
The Auditor-General for New South Wales, Margaret Crawford released her report today on key observations and findings from the 30 June 2018 financial statement audits of agencies in the Transport cluster. Unqualified audit opinions were issued for all agencies' financial statements. However, assessing the fair value of the broad range of transport related assets creates challenges.
This report analyses the results of our audits of financial statements of the Transport cluster for the year ended 30 June 2018. The table below summarises our key observations.
This report provides Parliament and other users of the Transport cluster’s financial statements with the results of our audits, our observations, analysis, conclusions and recommendations in the following areas:
- financial reporting
- audit observations.
Financial reporting is an important element of good governance. Confidence and transparency in public sector decision making are enhanced when financial reporting is accurate and timely.
This chapter outlines our audit observations related to the financial reporting of agencies in the Transport cluster for 2018.
| Observation | Conclusions and recommendations |
| 2.1 Quality of financial reporting | |
| Unqualified audit opinions were issued for all agencies' financial statements | Sufficient audit evidence was obtained to conclude the financial statements were free of material misstatement. |
| 2.2 Key accounting issues | |
| Valuation of assets continues to create challenges. Although agencies complied with the requirements of the accounting standards and Treasury policies on valuations, we identified some opportunities for improvements at RMS. |
RMS incorporated data from its asset condition assessments for the first time in the valuation methodology which improved the valuation outcome. Overall, we were satisfied with the valuation methodology and key assumptions, but we noted some deficiencies in the asset data in relation to asset component unit rates and old condition data for some components of assets. Also, a bypass and tunnel were incorrectly excluded from RMS records and valuation process since 2013. This resulted in an increase for these assets’ value by $133 million. The valuation inputs for Wetlands and Moorings were revised this year to better reflect the assets' characteristics resulting in a $98.0 million increase. |
| 2.3 Timeliness of financial reporting | |
| Residual Transport Corporation did not submit its financial statements by the statutory reporting deadline. | Residual Transport Corporation remained a dormant entity with no transactions for the year ended 30 June 2018. |
| With the exception of Residual Transport Corporation, all agencies completed early close procedures and submitted financial statements within statutory timeframes. | Early close procedures allow financial reporting issues and risks to be addressed early in the reporting and audit process. |
| 2.4 Financial sustainability | |
| NSW Trains and the Chief Investigator of the Office of Transport Safety Investigations reported negative net assets of $75.7 million and $89,000 respectively at 30 June 2018. | NSW Trains and the Chief Investigator of the Office of Transport Safety Investigations continue to require letters of financial support to confirm their ability to pay liabilities as they fall due. |
| 2.5 Passenger revenue and patronage | |
| Transport agencies revenue growth increased at a higher rate than patronage. | Public transport passenger revenue increased by $114 million (8.3 per cent) in 2017–18, and patronage increased by 37.1 million (5.1 per cent) across all modes of transport based on data provided by TfNSW. |
| Negative balance Opal Cards resulted in $3.8 million in revenue not collected in 2017–18 and $7.8 million since the introduction of Opal. A total of 1.1 million Opal cards issued since its introduction have negative balances. | Transport for NSW advised it is liaising with the ticketing vendor to implement system changes and are investigating other ways to reduce the occurrences. |
| 2.6 Cost recovery from public transport users | |
| Overall cost recovery from users has decreased. | Overall cost recovery from public transport users (on rail and bus services by STA) decreased from 23.2 per cent to 22.4 per cent between 2016–17 and 2017–18. The main reason for the decrease is due to expenditure increasing at a faster rate than revenue in 2017–18. |
Appropriate financial controls help ensure the efficient and effective use of resources and administration of agency policies. They are essential for quality and timely decision making.
This chapter outlines our observations and insights from:
- our financial statement audits of agencies in the Transport cluster for 2018
- the areas of focus identified in the Audit Office annual work program.
The Audit Office Annual Work Program provides a summary of all audits to be conducted within the proposed time period as well as detailed information on the areas of focus for each of the NSW Government clusters.
| Observation | Conclusions and recommendations |
| 3.1 Internal controls | |
| There was an increase in findings on internal controls across the Transport cluster. | Key themes related to information technology, employee leave entitlements and asset management. Eighteen per cent of all issues were repeat issues. |
| 3.2 Audit Office Annual work program | |
| The Transport cluster wrote-off over $200 million of assets which were replaced by new assets or technology. |
Majority of this write-off was recognised by RMS, with $199 million relating to the write-off of existing assets which have been replaced during the year. |
| RailCorp is expected to convert to TAHE from 1 July 2019. | Several working groups are considering different aspects of the TAHE transition including its status as a for-profit Public Trading Enterprise and which assets to transfer to TAHE. We will continue to monitor developments on TAHE for any impact to the financial statements. |
| RMS' estimated maintenance backlog at 30 June 2018 of $3.4 billion is lower than last year. Sydney Trains' estimated maintenance backlog at 30 June 2018 increased by 20.6 per cent to $434 million. TfNSW does not quantify its backlog maintenance. | TfNSW advised it is liaising with Infrastructure NSW to develop a consistent definition of maintenance backlog across all transport service providers. |
| Not all agencies monitor unplanned maintenance across the Transport cluster. | Unplanned maintenance can be more expensive than planned maintenance. TfNSW should develop a consistent approach to define, monitor and track unplanned maintenance across the cluster. |
This chapter outlines certain service delivery outcomes for 2017–18. The data on activity levels and performance is provided by Cluster agencies. The Audit Office does not have a specific mandate to audit performance information. Accordingly, the information in this chapter is unaudited.
We report this information on service delivery to provide additional context to understand the operations of the Transport cluster and to collate and present service information for different modes of transport in one report.
In our recent performance audit, Progress and measurement of Premier's Priorities, we identified 12 limitations of performance measurement and performance data. We recommended that the Department of Premier and Cabinet ensure that processes to check and verify data are in place for all agency data sources.
Universities 2017
The Auditor-General, Margaret Crawford released her report today on the results of financial audits of NSW universities for the year ended 31 December 2017. No qualified audit opinions were issued for any university and the quality and timeliness of financial reporting continues to improve.
This report analyses the results of our audits of financial statements of the ten NSW universities and their controlled entities for the year ended 31 December 2017. The table below summarises our key observations.
This report focuses on our observations on the common issues identified in our audits of the financial statements of the ten NSW universities and their controlled entities in 2017. The universities and controlled entities are listed in Appendix three and four respectively.
The report provides our analysis of universities’ results and findings in the following areas:
- Financial reporting and performance
- Teaching and research
- Financial controls and governance.
Accurate and timely financial reporting is important for universities to make efficient and effective economic decisions. Sound financial performance provides the platform for universities to deliver high quality teaching and research outcomes.
This chapter outlines our audit observations on the financial reporting and performance of NSW universities for 2017.
| Observation | Conclusion or recommendation |
| 3.1 Financial reporting | |
| Audit results | |
| The financial statements of all ten NSW universities and 66 out of 69 of their controlled entities received unmodified audit opinions. | Two controlled entities did not fully comply with the financial reporting and audit requirements of the Public Finance and Audit Act 1983 as they did not submit their financial statements to the Auditor-General. One of these entities was audited under the requirements applicable in its foreign jurisdiction. A third controlled entity submitted financial statements, but only after the statutory due date. |
| Quality and timeliness of financial reporting | |
| The number of uncorrected misstatements continues to decrease. | The quality of financial statements of the universities improved in 2017. |
| Two universities simplified disclosures in their financial statements. | The financial statements of the University of Sydney and Macquarie University are more concise, readable and understandable than those of other universities. |
| Six universities finalised their financial statements earlier than in previous years. | Universities that performed aspects of early close procedures improved the timeliness of their financial reporting and helped us conclude our audits earlier. |
| Eight universities are yet to quantify the impact of new accounting standards applicable in future years. | The two universities that have assessed the impact of the new accounting standards believe the impact will be material. |
| An accounting issue was identified relating to the recognition and measurement of payroll tax liabilities on employees' defined benefit superannuation contributions payable to the superannuation funds. | Recommendation: NSW universities should clarify the recognition and measurement of their liability for payroll tax on their defined benefit superannuation obligations before 31 December 2018. |
| 3.2 Financial performance | |
| Sources of revenue from operations | |
| Government grants as a proportion of total revenue decreased over the past five years by 6.4 per cent. |
The Australian Government announced funding freezes to Australian Government grants revenue for the next two years. Universities are expanding other revenue streams to decrease their reliance on grant funding. The revenue stream that has increased the most significantly over the past five years is overseas student revenue. |
| Revenue from overseas student course fees increased by 23 per cent in the last year and contributed $2.8 billion to the NSW university sector in 2017. | Overseas student revenue exceeded domestic student revenue by 37 per cent, and comprised over a quarter of NSW universities' total revenues in 2017. The growth in overseas student revenue has not been shared equally in the sector. Some universities are more dependent on overseas student revenue than others. |
| Revenue from overseas students from four countries comprised 37 per cent of total student revenues for all NSW universities. | Recommendation: NSW universities should assess their student market concentration risk where they rely heavily on students from a single country of origin. This increases their sensitivity to economic or political changes in that country. Universities' data shows as much as 71 per cent of their overseas student revenue comes from a single country of origin. |
| Research income of NSW universities was $1.1 billion in 2016 and has grown by 9.8 per cent between 2012 and 2016. | Two universities attracted 65.2 per cent of the total research income received by all NSW universities. |
| Other revenues | |
| Total philanthropic revenue increased by 1.0 per cent to $151 million in 2017. |
Philanthropic revenue has been increasing for the past five years. Two universities attracted 76.8 per cent of the total philanthropic dollars received by all NSW universities. |
| Average investment returns fell from 7.0 per cent in 2013 to 5.8 per cent in 2017, while total investments grew to $5.4 billion in 2017 from $3.5 billion in 2013. |
Universities have structured their investment portfolios between fixed and non-fixed income assets, seeking to optimise their returns in a low interest rate environment within the limits of their risk management strategies. Investment income is a significant source of revenue for some, but not all universities. Two universities' investment funds represented 52.3 per cent of the total investment funds of all NSW universities combined. |
| Low interest rates have made investment in fixed income assets less attractive for universities. Over the last five years universities have increased their investment in non-fixed income (or market based) assets by 67.1 per cent. | |
| Most NSW universities have established investment governance frameworks. | |
| Financial sustainability indicators | |
| Operating expenditure per equivalent full-time student load (EFTSL) increased by 3.0 per cent in 2017. | The universities that have been able to attract international students to grow their operational revenues have been able to leverage economies of scale to maximise their average margin per EFTSL. Other universities have had to rely on containing costs to achieve higher EFTSL margins. |
| For six universities, the growth in operating expenditure has exceeded the growth in operating revenue, reducing operating margins. The risk associated with narrowing margins is compounded where universities have a high reliance on student revenues from a single source. Sudden changes in demand can challenge the ability of those universities to adjust their cost structures. |
As the margin between operating revenue and operating expenditure decreases, operational results are more at risk from unexpected fluctuations, such as Australian Government higher education reforms and reduced overseas student enrolments. Smaller operating margins reduce the funds available to invest in upgrading infrastructure and implement corporate strategies to meet future challenges. |
| Eight universities have current ratios greater than one in 2017. | |
| Controlled entities | |
| Sixteen of the universities' 58 controlled entities that operate business activities reported losses in 2017 (15 in 2016). | Overall, the financial performance of controlled entities operating business activities was positive, but results in 2017 were lower than in 2016. |
| The total profit of controlled entities operating business activities decreased 5.5 per cent to $77.5 million in 2017 ($82.6 million in 2016). | Universities may be able to improve their overall performance by reassessing the viability of business ventures that continue to make losses and/or rely on them for financial support. |
| Eighteen controlled entities relied on guarantees of financial support from their parent entity in 2017 (19 in 2016). | |
Teaching and research are key objectives of universities and they invest most of their resources in achieving high quality academic and research outcomes to maintain or advance their reputations and rankings in Australia and abroad. Universities have also committed to achieving certain government objectives.
This chapter outlines teaching and research outcomes for NSW universities for 2017.
| Observation | Conclusion or recommendation |
| 4.1 Teaching outcomes | |
| Achieving Australian Government target | |
| NSW universities met the Australian Government target of having 40 per cent of 25 to 34 year-olds with bachelor degrees ten years earlier than the original target date of 2025. |
The proportion of 25 to 34 year-olds in NSW holding a bachelor degree increased to 43.4 per cent in 2017. In 2009, when the target was originally set, only 35.5 per cent of 25 to 34 year-olds held a bachelor degree. |
| Graduate employment rates | |
|
Seven universities exceeded the national average of 71.8 per cent for the proportion of their undergraduates who obtain full-time employment. Four universities achieved better than the national average of 86.1 per cent for the proportion of their postgraduates who obtain full-time employment. |
Most NSW universities' employment outcomes are better than the national average. |
| Student enrolments by field of education | |
| NSW universities have increased enrolments in fields of study that align with known skills shortages in NSW identified by the Australian Government for 2016 and 2017. | Alignment of student intake with identified shortages helps ensure graduates secure timely employment on completion of their studies. |
| Achieving diversity outcomes | |
|
NSW universities agreed to targets set by the Australian Government for enrolments of students from low socio economic status (SES) and Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander backgrounds. |
NSW universities can improve outcomes for these students by implementing policies to increase enrolments and support students to graduation. |
|
Three universities exceeded the target of 20 per cent of low SES student enrolments in 2017. Six universities met their Indigenous student enrolment target in 2017. The target is having a growth rate in the enrolment of Indigenous students that is more than 50 per cent higher than the growth rate of non-Indigenous student enrolments. |
At the current rate, it is unlikely most universities will reach the agreed low SES target by 2020. |
Appropriate financial controls help ensure efficient and effective use of resources, and the implementation and monitoring of university policies. Governance consists of frameworks, processes and behaviours that enable the universities to operate effectively and comply with relevant laws and policies.
This chapter outlines our audit observations on the financial control and governance of NSW universities for 2017.
| Observation | Conclusion or recommendation |
| 5.1 Internal controls | |
| Internal control findings | |
|
Eighty-three internal control deficiencies were identified during our audits, of which 40 related to Information Technology (IT). |
Recommendation: NSW universities should ensure controls, including information technology controls, are properly designed and operate effectively to protect intellectual property, staff and student data, and assets. Universities should rectify identified deficiencies in a timely manner. |
| Repeat findings Twenty-four findings were repeat internal control deficiencies, of which 18 related to IT. |
IT issues can take some time to rectify because specialist skill and/or partnering with software suppliers is often required to implement new controls. However, until rectified, the vulnerabilities those control deficiencies present can be significant. |
| Cyber security Our audits identified opportunities to improve cyber security controls and processes to reduce risks, including risks relating to financial loss, reputational damage and breaches of privacy laws. |
Recommendation: NSW universities should strengthen their cyber security frameworks to manage cyber security risks. This includes developing:
|
|
Use of credit card and work-related travel The risks of unauthorised use can be mitigated by regular monitoring, and reporting breaches for investigation and disciplinary action. |
Appropriately designed and implemented preventive and detective controls are most effective when enforcement and disciplinary activities are oversighted by university audit and risk committees. |
Volume Four 2015 Treasury and State Finances
For the third consecutive year, the General Government and Total State Sector Accounts received an unqualified auditor’s opinion following more than a decade of qualifications.
Errors in agencies’ financial statements and the Total State Sector Accounts were corrected as necessary to ensure compliance with Australian Accounting Standards and the requirements of the Public Finance and Audit Act 1983.
Improvements to year-end financial reporting processes have enabled the Audit Office to issue 229 audit opinions by 2 October 2015, compared to only 67 by the same time in 2011.
Volume Two 2015 focusing on Universities
Generally, NSW universities are in a sound financial position, but average operating margins are falling and operating expenditure is growing faster than operative revenue.
The university sector’s average operating margin fell from 6.6 per cent in 2013 to 4.8 per cent in 2014 and combined operating expenditure grew 0.9 per cent more than operating revenue. Employee expenses in 2014 increased by an average of 5.1 per cent and other expenses by 5.8 per cent.
Operating expenditure grew at a faster pace than operating revenue at six of the ten NSW universities.
